Reviews — Return to Silent Hill
Audience write-ups from TMDB
Sierbahnn
The film’s appearance is remarkable; however, it feels hollow. It seems like all of the filmmakers' energy was devoted to creating an unsettling atmosphere instead of actually generating suspense. The feeling of unease isn't even mildly interesting, much less frightening, and the characters are disappointing while the plot itself is unremarkable. I suspect people familiar with the video games might find something …
Gordon
It's rare to find a video game adaptation that feels this authentic; I can honestly say this one captures 99% of the source material. Among all such films, its accuracy is remarkable—almost unsettling. The storyline involving a group with extreme beliefs felt unpleasant, but as is often the case when adapting from a video game or book, some changes were made. Regardless, it proved to be an enjoyable film, even …
jackmeat
My initial score is 4.9 out of 10. Seeing that Bloody Disgusting logo at the beginning always makes you wonder what to expect. Sometimes it's a sign for something good, and other times it’s a warning. Return to Silent Hill falls somewhere in between those two extremes. A painter named James Sunderland (Jeremy Irvine), haunted by memories and regret, is drawn to Room 318 because of a handwritten note from his missi…
Dean
I saw the original Silent Hill film and thought it was really good. I’ve also played Silent Hill 2, which I consider to be excellent within its category, and recently watched this movie as well. It’s hard to describe my thoughts about this one... The filmmakers succeeded in capturing the look of the game; it's remarkably similar, and they did a decent job recreating that aesthetic. They altered some aspects of the st…
CinemaSerf
I honestly don’t recall seeing “Silent Hill” when it initially came out back in 2006, and now I'm positive I won't be revisiting it. While director Christopher Gans did at least make a sensible choice casting someone who isn’t unpleasant to look at as the main character, even Jeremy Irvine’s pale appearance couldn’t inject any vitality into this film. He portrays “James,” who encounters “Mary” (Hannah Emily Anderson)…
MovieGuys
It’s a real problem when a movie needs more than half an hour just to become mildly diverting, at least in my view. "Return to Silent Hill" failed to deliver excitement or suspense; frankly, I was bored watching it. The cast did what they could, giving acceptable performances, but the narrative itself really needed some changes to make it captivating. Basically, while the acting wasn’t bad, I thought the story …


