Reviews — Sleepy Hollow
Audience write-ups from TMDB
CinemaSerf
Johnny Depp delivers what may very well be my favorite performance of his career. Drawing from Irving Washington’s captivatingly eerie story, he portrays the rational Constable "Ichabod Crane," sent by Christopher Lee – another familiar face in Tim Burton’s films – to look into a puzzling killing within the quiet Dutch community named in the title. Upon arrival, he finds that the locals, deeply entrenched in their be…
GenerationofSwine
There’s no denying the actors are talented and perform admirably. However, what emerges is essentially Tim asserting his unwillingness to engage with the source material—a recurring pattern. It mirrors his approach to Batman and every other adaptation he’s touched. I once knew a woman in college who professed an enthusiasm for numerous books, yet she only ever claimed to have read "The Mists of Avalon"—and she …
Wuchak
"Sleepy Hollow," Tim Burton's 1999 interpretation of Washington Irving’s classic story about Ichabod Crane and the Headless Horseman, features Johnny Depp as Crane and Christopher Walken portraying the Hessian horseman. The narrative unfolds in 1799 and centers on Crane, a constable from New York City, who travels to the Dutch settlement of Sleepy Hollow to investigate a series of brutal murders where victims are beh…
Kamurai
It’s an enjoyable film that I could see myself watching again, and I would suggest others check it out. Johnny Depp and Christina Ricci certainly have significant roles, but there's a great deal more happening in the movie as well. The Headless Horseman is central to the narrative, much like in the source material. I didn’t find the original story about the Headless Horseman particularly substantial, so most ad…
John Chard
You’re now being tested, Ichabod Crane. Tim Burton directed Sleepy Hollow, and Andrew Kevin Walker and Kevin Yagher adapted the screenplay from Washington Irving's "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow." The film features Johnny Depp, Christina Ricci, Miranda Richardson, Marc Pickering, Michael Gambon, Jeffrey Jones, and Casper Van Dien. Danny Elfman composed the music, and Emmanuel Lubezki was in charge of cinematography.…
Dark Jedi
I want to be upfront: I don't believe Johnny Depp was the ideal choice to portray Ichabod Crane. Perhaps my perception is colored by his performances in Pirates of The Caribbean, but he simply didn’t seem right for the part. He just didn’t resonate with me. To my mind, his mannerisms and exaggerated gestures prevented him from being believable as a crime investigator who relies on scientific reasoning. It's disapp…


