René Clair’s direction makes this a truly excellent version of one of Agatha Christie's more captivating murder mysteries, and I believe it remains unmatched even after roughly 75 years. A wonderful group of actors are brought together for a weekend getaway on an isolated island by hosts they’ve never encountered before. Upon arrival, their host—through a recording—accuses each guest of committing terrible acts; then…

It's a shame to see such a promising beginning lead to something so underwhelming. Adapted from Agatha Christie’s well-regarded novel, initially titled Ten Little Indians, this “thriller” falls far short of expectations. Featuring an impressive lineup of performers like Barry Fitzgerald, Walter Houston, Louis Hayward, and Roland Young, and helmed by Rene Clair, one might reasonably expect a classic mystery thrille…