W2TCH

Poisoned in Paradise: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery (2021)

2021 • 1h 24m • Mystery, TV Movie • TV-G
IMDb6.7/10882TMDB71%18Rotten Tomatoes—Metacritic—
Search trailer
On September 25, 2026
#44562▼ 5104
44562nd by Pulse movie online
12.2PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

Most Popular Poisoned in Paradise: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery Cast Members

Jesse Metcalfe is the most popular Poisoned in Paradise: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery cast member right now, with a Popularity Score of 2.42. Updated September 27, 2026.

#
Cast
Popularity
1

Jesse Metcalfe

Jeff "J. W." Jackson/42 years during filming
2.4
2

Eric Keenleyside

Chief Madieras/63 years during filming
1.7
3

Sarah Lind

Zee Madieras/38 years during filming
1.7
4

Britt McKillip

Katie Leonard/30 years during filming
1.6
5

Lucia Walters

Amanda Peterson
1.6
6

Paul Moniz de Sa

Frankie
1.4
7

Lossen Chambers

Myrna
1.3
8

Brent Stait

Sgt. Webber/61 years during filming
1.3
9

Reilly Dolman

Glen Eads/33 years during filming
1.3
10

Tammy Gillis

Lauren Cabot/49 years during filming
1.2
11

Chelsea Hobbs

Jackie Shawl/36 years during filming
1.1
12

Sunita Prasad

Britt Prajna
1.1
13

Nelson Wong

Detective Andy Lau
1.1
14

Ian Rozylo

Keith McDonough
1.0
15

Austin Anozie

Officer Davis
0.9
16

Nhi Do

Hazel/34 years during filming
0.9
17

Manoj Sood

Marty Cline/59 years during filming
0.8
18

Eric Yue

Guard
0.7
19

Jasmine Lukuku

Claire Hollis
0.7
20

Drew Henderson

Noah Cabot
0.6
21

Chelsea de Puyjalon

Barista
0.3