W2TCH

Would You Kill for Me? The Mary Bailey Story (2023)

2023 • 1h 30m • Drama, Thriller • TV-14
JustWatch▲ +6#14521IMDb6.1/10409TMDB78%11Rotten Tomatoes—Metacritic—
On September 26, 2026
#53060▲ 8871
53060th by Pulse movie online
10.1PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

Most Popular Would You Kill for Me? The Mary Bailey Story Cast Members

Melissa Joan Hart is the most popular Would You Kill for Me? The Mary Bailey Story cast member right now, with a Popularity Score of 2.14. Updated September 27, 2026.

#
Cast
Popularity
1

Melissa Joan Hart

Ella/47 years during filming
2.1
2

Olivia Scriven

Veronica/26 years during filming
1.3
3

Connor McMahon

Willard Simms/25 years during filming
1.0
4

Michael Gordin Shore

▲ 0.2Angus/57 years during filming
0.9
5

Isabella Astbury

Young Mary Bailey
0.8
6

JaNae Armogan

Police Woman
0.7
7

Paulyne Wei

Celine
0.7
8

Presley Allard

Mary Bailey
0.7
9

Luca Thunberg

Sammy Bailey/8 years during filming
0.6
10

Dana Fradkin

Jennifer
0.5
11

Pierre Simpson

▼ 0.2Pastor McCall
0.5
12

Patrick Ludlow

Background performer (Police)/120 years during filming
0.5
13

Celina Myers

Susan (uncredited)
0.5
14

Laura Adamo

Cordelia
0.4