W2TCH

Should've Been Romeo (2012)

2012 • 1h 30m • Drama, Comedy
IMDb5.4/10111TMDB43%3Rotten Tomatoes—Metacritic—
Search trailer
On September 25, 2026
#34829▼ 485
34829th by Pulse movie online
15.2PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

Most Popular Should've Been Romeo Cast Members

Natasha Henstridge is the most popular Should've Been Romeo cast member right now, with a Popularity Score of 3.43. Updated September 26, 2026.

#
Cast
Popularity
1

Natasha Henstridge

37 years during filming
3.4
2

Michael Rapaport

Danny/42 years during filming
3.4
3

Eric Andre

Buzz/29 years during filming
3.2
4

Tina Majorino

Alice/27 years during filming
3.0
5

Costas Mandylor

Mason/46 years during filming
2.7
6

Paul Ben-Victor

Joey/46 years during filming
2.5
7

Carol Kane

Ruth/59 years during filming
2.5
8

Ed Asner

Charlie/82 years during filming
2.4
9

Mary McCormack

Ellen/43 years during filming
2.2
10

Kelly Osbourne

Nicole/27 years during filming
2.2
11

Vincent Ventresca

Matt/45 years during filming
1.9
12

Evan Handler

Stewart/51 years during filming
1.7
13

Renée Taylor

Tillie/79 years during filming
1.6
14

B.J. Britt

T.J./29 years during filming
1.1
15

Josh Cowdery

Jaffe/33 years during filming
0.9
16

Christian J. Meoli

Eddie/39 years during filming
0.9
17

Howard Rosenman

Henry/67 years during filming
0.9
18

Garrett Brawith

Pickle/37 years during filming
0.7
19

Jordenn Thompson

Billie
0.6
20

Theo Alexander

Milton
0.6
21

Sam Hale

James
0.4