W2TCH

Careful What You Wish For (2016)

2016 • 1h 31m • Drama, Thriller • R
JustWatch▲ +19#6584IMDb5.6/109,419TMDB61%421Rotten Tomatoes17%Metacritic32
On September 29, 2026
#4939▲ 2403
4939th by Pulse movie online
44.0PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

Most Popular Careful What You Wish For Cast Members

Dermot Mulroney is the most popular Careful What You Wish For cast member right now, with a Popularity Score of 5.00. Updated September 30, 2026.

#
Cast
Popularity
1

Dermot Mulroney

Eliott Harper/52 years during filming
5.0
2

Kevin J. O'Connor

Pier/Patron du bar/52 years during filming
3.6
3

Isabel Lucas

Lena Harper/31 years during filming
2.6
4

Nick Jonas

Doug Martin/23 years during filming
2.1
5

Paul Sorvino

Sheriff Big Jack/77 years during filming
2.1
6

Kandyse McClure

Angie Alvarez/36 years during filming
2.1
7

Graham Rogers

Carson/25 years during filming
1.9
8

Marc Macaulay

Gordon/58 years during filming
1.7
9

David Sherrill

Brian Martin/56 years during filming
1.2
10

Alex ter Avest

Emma Shalloway
1.1
11

Ross Gallo

Lena's Lawyer
0.7
12

John Driskell Hopkins

Gus/45 years during filming
0.5