For many in Generation X, the “Brat Pack” represents a fondly remembered era when a group of young actors dominated entertainment during the mid-1980s. Stars like Rob Lowe, Ally Sheedy, Demi Moore, Emilio Estevez, Molly Ringwald, and Judd Nelson were at their peak, but that level of fame and the label itself brought years of sadness, regret, and hardship. Andrew McCarthy, an original member of this group, created …

Andrew McCarthy’s newest documentary held promise—it seemed like it could be a wonderful trip down memory lane, connected to an era that shaped so many people. But ultimately, it didn't quite work out, largely because of McCarthy himself. As someone who enjoys the movies made by the "Brat Pack," I feel this documentary missed its chance in several important ways. This ninety-minute film feels more like a long comp…