Reviews — A Tree Grows in Brooklyn
Audience write-ups from TMDB
CinemaSerf
Around 1900, the Nolan family was struggling to survive in New York City. The mother, “Katie” (played by Dorothy Maguire), attempted to guide her young and easily influenced daughter, "Francie" (Peggy Ann Garner), and son, “Neeley” (Ted Donaldson), while their father—a kind but alcoholic performer (James Dunn)—found it difficult to hold down a job and often turned to drink. Adding to the mix was the spirited aunt “Si…
barrymost
The film provides a lovely take on Betty Smith’s well-regarded book, managing to be both touching and deeply sad. The performances are captivating throughout, and it’s unusual to see such a consistently strong ensemble. Peggy Ann Garner and James Dunn stand out especially; it's noteworthy that their careers declined significantly in the years following this production. They create a wonderful dynamic as a spirited yo…

