Following the dissolution of their respective marriages, Oscar and Felix, who had been college roommates, resolve to share a home.

When Oscar is brought on to ghostwrite the autobiography of a retired baseball player, Felix readily offers his assistance.

The realization struck Oscar with a sharp, unwelcome clarity: he had forgotten Felix’s birthday. A wave of guilt washed over him, quickly followed by a determined resolve. He would make amends. An impromptu celebration was the only solution…

Dani regretted not having a boyfriend for her high school reunion, so Oscar, Felix, and Ted took it upon themselves to find her one.

At the wedding of a mutual acquaintance, Oscar hopes to rekindle a past romance, while Felix intends to impress his ex-wife with a display of personal transformation.

Felix's anxieties escalate sharply when Oscar begins a relationship with the one person whose professional opinion matters most to him: his physician.

Felix persuaded Oscar to appear on a sports television program, a decision directly contrary to Teddy's counsel to remain focused on his radio work.

A flicker of unease stirred within Oscar as he witnessed Felix's unexpected prowess on the softball field and the basketball court. A silent challenge passed between them, culminating in a proposal: a decathlon, a contest of ten athletic ev…

Oscar and Felix journeyed to Ashley’s, their destination a familiar quest for a cherished pillow – one Felix had kept hidden from his friend. The retrieval of the pillow would bring an unexpected revelation.

Felix's substitute teaching of a yoga class proves jarring to everyone present, including Emily. Meanwhile, Oscar and Dani find themselves unexpectedly confined to a subway car, further fueling their discontent with city life. Adding to the…

A peculiar fixation takes hold of Oscar when he learns of his companion's past. The woman he is seeing, it turns out, once courted the celebrated former baseball star, and Oscar finds himself strangely compelled to measure up to the legend …

Upon the IRS’s decision to audit Oscar and his ex-wife, Gaby, Felix volunteered to mediate their fraught relationship. He soon found himself with a disquieting realization: he might be the cause of Oscar's audit all along.