Gabe launched into a college preparation pep talk for his students, but the exercise unravelled with such dramatic failure that it sparked a profound self-doubt within him, forcing him to reconsider the very course of his own life.

Gabe’s students found themselves embroiled in a series of mishaps after he enthusiastically suggested they enroll in Carlos’s drama class. Meanwhile, Paula pressed the staff to sample a newly opened establishment.

Gabe inserts himself into Paula’s romantic prospects when she secures a date with a prominent coach, a man known for his charm. Meanwhile, Marisol resists the idea of taking a leading role in the school production.

Gabe’s attempts at kindness invariably bring unforeseen consequences, and his enthusiastic support of Marisol’s entry into the district’s Green Week competition will prove no exception. He remains oblivious to the cost of his good intention…

Marisol, citing concerns about cultural appropriation, targeted Gabe’s favorite taco truck. Meanwhile, Paula made a move to censor the school’s upcoming production of "Romeo and Juliet."

Gabe’s friends gently urged him to resume dating, but he instead encouraged Paula to seek out a new guidance counselor. Meanwhile, Mikey wrestled with the prospect of kissing Marisol during their performance.