Following his tense encounter with Brad’s father, who brazenly recounted tales of Lily and Brad’s intimacy, Sean turned his attention to Claudia, only to discover she was already privy to the rumors. Consequently, when Brad sustains a pecul…

Claudia decided it was high time to mend the strained ties between the two families, planning a dinner for the O'Keefes. The evening, however, dissolved into discord when Brad’s mother laid blame squarely on Lily, accusing her of stealing B…

To keep their bar afloat, Sean and Eddie resort to hiring strippers, a decision that soon draws the ire of the local PTA. The true source of their outrage, however, is far more surprising. Separately, Brad asks Lily to end her relationship …

Sean felt a sting of frustration watching Lily’s discomfort around Brad, and he resolved to shed his awkward persona. His efforts, however, backfired spectacularly, resulting in another student’s suspension. This incident escalated into a t…

Brad envisioned a romantic evening with Lily in New York City. However, a single unforeseen event derailed their plans, and the remainder of the night spiraled into a series of unfortunate circumstances. Elsewhere, Eddie’s clumsy action sha…

The looming SATs cast a shadow of worry over Lily and Brad, their anxieties mounting with each passing day. Claudia, however, transformed the impending tests into a spirited competition amongst them. Elsewhere, Sean offered Henry a valuable…

Eddie purchased an electric car with the intention of impressing a girl, a decision that proved to have unforeseen consequences. Sean, without informing Claudia, extended Eddie a loan, which subsequently led to her college enrollment check …

The morning after a night of revelry found Lily with a throbbing headache and a car parked on her porch, a complete blank where memories should have been. Sean and Claudia, seeking to offer her a lesson, resolved to sell the vehicle and ha…

Sean initiated a conversation with Jimmy regarding matters of courtship and intimacy, while Brad inadvertently witnessed Claudia in a state of undress.

A flicker of jealousy ignited within Sean when Claudia received an invitation to model for a fashion photographer. Hurt and frustrated, she abruptly left, abandoning him to manage the bath products party she had so carefully arranged. Elsew…

Sean and Eddie entered the bar to find it violated. A robbery had occurred. Rather than summon the authorities, Walt, with an unsettling calmness, insisted on tidying the mess. Elsewhere, Lily and Brad spent the day at the mall, their time …

Sean yearned for a Sex Pistols concert, but Claudia faced a looming college exam and Lily had a science project due, leaving the boys unattended. Lily, however, circumvented the situation by slipping away to a fraternity party, where she un…

A bitter edge lingered in Lily’s feelings toward her former boyfriend, a resentment sharpened by his effortless transition after their separation. Meanwhile, Eddie’s comedy struggled until he began weaving anecdotes drawn from the private l…

Claudia’s professor had entrusted Sean with a vital message, one that slipped his mind. Meanwhile, Jimmy concealed the telephone bill, desperate to hide his calls to a 976 exchange. And Lily, consumed by anxiety, spiraled when Brad failed t…

On their romantic hotel stay, Claudia and Sean stumble upon an adult film and are struck by the unsettling realization that it appears to have been filmed in their own house. The film sparks a strange thought in Claudia's mind: the girl who…

Seeking respite from the everyday, Sean and Claudia embraced the quiet solitude of an unoccupied house, cherishing their time together. Meanwhile, Lily observed Brad's attempts at dancing and concluded, with a gentle certainty, that he poss…

At school, Lily, Brad, and Jimmy alike signed pledges promising abstinence. Brad, emboldened by this shared commitment, asked Lily for her hand in marriage. Jimmy, in stark contrast, began discarding anything that conjured thoughts of sex. …

Dan, Brad's father (guest star Gregory Jbara), maintains he’s been diligently taking tennis lessons for years. But after Sean (Donal Logue) defeats him in a match, the truth emerges: Dan’s been having an affair, and the tennis lessons were …

The Finnertys organized a birthday celebration for Brad, hoping to offer him a distraction from his parents’ recent separation. Sean, harboring a secret, invited Brad’s father, believing it would aid in reuniting him with his wife, Connie (…

Claudia made a deliberate decision to exclude Brad from the family portrait. Meanwhile, her father-in-law, played by Richard Riehle, confided in her a peculiar story about his deceased feline companion.

Eddie coaxed Sean into assisting him with a plan: to enter the apartment of his former girlfriend and take photographs that would undoubtedly prove humiliating to her.

The bar’s precarious state weighs heavily on Sean, and Claudia gently urges him to reconsider his decision to close it. With St. Patrick's Day fast approaching, Eddie attempts to draw patrons away from competing establishments. Elsewhere, B…

Sean offered a sharp rebuke to one of Henry’s ill-mannered companions. Lily implored Brad to make a choice: her or his close circle of enthusiasts. Meanwhile, Eddie navigated the world of online Jewish dating.

Claudia meticulously copied Lily’s school paper, unaware that the essay itself was plagiarized. Sean cautiously mentioned to Sister Helen the possibility of academic dishonesty, but discovered too late the severity of the school’s "zero-tol…

Tony, Claudia’s father, is back with the Finnertys for surgery, and the family offers him their support, all except for Sean.

Claudia, striving to ease Sean’s hypertension and manage his high blood pressure, shoulders the entire burden of the household, but her efforts unravel one by one. The fallout from Jimmy's suspension from school creates a cascade of complic…

A shadow of discontent settled over Lily as Brad's demanding new occupation consumed his every waking moment. Elsewhere, Walt struggled to secure employment, prompting Sean and Eddie to offer him a position at the bar. However, their hopes …

A shadow of uncertainty crossed Lily's face as Brad recounted a past connection with a girl named Lana, forged during a space camp visit. Weary of Lily’s persistent skepticism, Brad altered his summer plans. He boarded a bus, destination: s…