This reimagining draws from a long-standing series inspired by classic books. Revivals often fall short, but I believe this one hits its stride: it still has some cheesy moments, yet feels intelligent, considered, and modernized. I’ve even come to prefer it over the initial run. This isn't due to any shortcomings in the original cast—they were excellent across the board. My appreciation stems from the way the new version handles the storyline and dialogue. You naturally anticipate alterations from the source material, just as the first series deviated from the books. I wouldn’t want to see a carbon copy with different faces. The key difference lies in how those adjustments are implemented. To illustrate my point without revealing too much, the scene involving Tristan gathering payments on market day is presented differently than it was before, connecting that storyline to James's dealings with a champion racehorse. This made the plot feel more cohesive. Other shifts move away from purely comedic, almost silly situations toward something more dramatic, though still containing humor. I commend the production team for honoring the spirit of the books while making worthwhile changes to keep the story feeling new and enjoyable. *** I’m adding a comment after watching the Christmas special that aired near the holidays. That episode essentially reinforces everything I mentioned about the show earlier. The departures from the original series continued, with further development of the subplot involving Mrs. Hall and a notably different portrayal of James Herriot's romantic relationships. However, the resolution wasn’t sensationalized like some programs would do. Siegfried and Tristan are given more layers as well. This production isn’t played purely for laughs as much as the original was, although humor is still present, and it continues to impress me.

Source on TMDB