Synopsis

With a fondness for both cookies and pies, host Jesse Palmer challenges nine bakers to create holiday mini pies adorned with cookies. Judges Nancy Fuller, Duff Goldman, and Carla Hall assess the festive competition as the bakers showcase autumnal flavors—pumpkin-cider and chestnut-chocolate among them—in a variety of presentations: double-crust, cream pies, slab pies, lattice pies, and custard pies.