This reviewer found "Talamasca: The Secret Order" immediately disappointing. It’s burdened by familiar and expected progressive themes—discussions of “fairness” and “discrimination,” for instance—which felt tiresome. It seems many viewers are weary of this kind of content and unwilling to engage with it. Compounding the problem, the pacing is sluggish, giving the show the feel of a supernatural soap opera rather than something more compelling. The few positive aspects include decent performances and acceptable production quality; little else was noteworthy. Ultimately, it's another series that had potential for excitement, perhaps even a resemblance to shows like "Supernatural," but instead delivers lectures. I won’t be watching further episodes.

Source on TMDB