The initial portion, roughly the first half-hour, wasn’t terrible, even considering what seems to be a decline in Ratner's directing skills and Scott's unnecessary demise. However, it goes sharply downhill afterward. With Ratner at the helm, everything feels just a bit inferior. The script quality suffers, the direction lacks imagination, and any attempts at social commentary are noticeably diluted compared to previous installments. I didn’t find Charles’ death problematic, nor was I bothered by how it happened; it's logical that Phoenix would eliminate him. My issue is that his passing doesn’t lead to anything substantial beyond prompting the X-Men to take action they were already planning on taking. This isn't the only supposedly significant event that ultimately proves inconsequential. Pyro appears poised to betray Magneto after witnessing his actions against Mystique, but he never does. Rogue departs to seek a cure and her absence has no real impact other than a cameo at the film’s conclusion; it doesn’t alter the plot or affect any of the character dynamics—she simply disappears, returns, and all is well again. I believe a fundamental flaw within the original X-Men series lies in their apparent obsession with Wolverine and their dismissal of Cyclops. He plays a minimal role in the first two films before meeting his end here, which diminishes the emotional weight of his death. Given that *X2* already centered heavily on Logan's story arc, I feel it should have been Scott’s character who received greater development. It would have had more impact if he were to undergo significant growth throughout this movie and then be responsible for killing Jean. The connection between Logan and Jean never felt authentic enough to make the film’s ending believable. Jean Grey is essential to the narrative's core, yet she's relegated to a secondary role, treated like an object rather than a character, until her death.

Source on TMDB