W2TCH

Witness (1985)

1985 • 1h 52m • Drama, Thriller • R
On October 4, 2026
#4503
4503rd by Pulse movie online
4.5PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

All reviews

Filipe Manuel Neto on Witness

8/10 · Jun 2, 2024

**A movie blending action and a look at Amish life.** Here in Portugal, we don’t have communities like the Amish, Mennonite or similar groups, so this particular religious community really captures my attention—though it’s complicated. I strongly disagree with their beliefs; I wouldn't want to be part of such a group. Still, I find it interesting that they try to live a simpler life in today’s world, away from excessive technology and more in tune with nature. It’s a lifestyle I might even like to experience, even though I know adapting would be difficult without the technologies I use for work and entertainment. The film follows a police officer who discovers corruption within his department and must go into hiding to avoid being killed while protecting the only witness to a murder of another officer: an Amish boy living with his mother, a widow, and her father in a secluded rural area that isn’t very welcoming to outsiders—whom they refer to as “the English.” Throughout the story, we see their customs, beliefs, and how these strict religious communities have rejected anything considered luxurious, choosing instead a stoic existence based on basic farming. I won't comment on how realistic the plot is, but I think the script tried to create a believable story that works. It even received an Oscar for Best Original Screenplay, which says something. What I can say is that while the film holds your attention, there are areas where it could be better: the identities of the killers and villains should have remained a mystery longer, and their reasons aren't entirely clear to me. Also, the fate of the young Amish widow’s husband wasn’t fully explained. The tension between her and the community leaders could have been explored more thoroughly, as well as how the community accepts or rejects the police officer. Peter Weir directed this film, which faced difficulties securing funding and didn't receive much support from the Amish community—who not only avoid being filmed but also worry about attracting crowds of curious people seeking souvenirs and photos. Technically, it’s outstanding: beyond the good cinematography, excellent editing (another Oscar win), and well-done action sequences, the sets and costumes are great, perfectly recreating the environment and simple way of life of the Amish. One negative point is Kelly McGillis's nude scene; it feels unnecessary and doesn't fit with the story. After a series of fantastic and sci-fi films, Harrison Ford took on a different kind of role, one he would pursue more often in the years that followed: the action hero, armed and ready to do whatever it takes to save the day. He seems very comfortable in this role and delivers excellent work, fully deserving his Oscar nomination for Best Actor. Kelly McGillis does an adequate job but doesn’t stand out negatively. Danny Glover is believable as a villain.

Source on TMDB