The complexities of homelessness and substance abuse are undeniable, particularly for those living through them. Even with programs designed to help, many people remain unsympathetic, which only complicates efforts toward recovery. Gaining public support for these issues can be tough, and one approach is to show the daily struggles faced by those affected. This is where the directorial debut from Harris Dickinson could have resonated, but ultimately falls short. The film follows Mike (Frank Dillane), a man in recovery who spent time in prison after attacking someone trying to help him, documenting his attempts to rebuild his life upon release. However, the storytelling feels scattered and wanders aimlessly, resembling a collection of unconnected incidents without any clear purpose. There's very little background information provided, and Mike’s character doesn’t seem to develop much throughout the story. It’s even questionable whether his portrayal truly represents what the film’s title suggests. Because viewers don’t really get to know him, it’s hard to become invested in his fate or feel sympathy for those facing similar challenges. Adding to this confusion are several dreamlike sequences that don't offer any extra insight, either literally or figuratively. Considering how little the movie manages to create a cohesive argument for these important causes, I am surprised by the overwhelmingly positive reaction it has received, including awards from film festivals and critics’ groups. “Urchin” was recognized as one of the Top 10 Independent Films of 2025 by the National Board of Review, and won two out of four nominations at the 2025 Cannes Film Festival, notably a best actor award for Dillane (and while he delivers a solid performance, it’s hard to see why it would be considered top honors). Each year there are films that receive an unusual amount of praise without fully deserving it, and this feels like one of those for 2025. It's unfortunate that the film didn't do more to highlight the issues at its heart; it’s hard to offer assistance when you lack a clear understanding of how to proceed.

Source on TMDB