The film offers a thoughtful and restrained portrayal of JRR Tolkien’s formative years, focusing on his personal connections, academic pursuits, and the trauma he endured during World War One. Nicholas Hoult delivers a nuanced and believable performance in the central role, while Colm Meaney, Sir Derek Jacobi, and Lily Collins provide solid supporting work. The depiction of wartime scenes relies on atmospheric elements like lighting and sound design to convey their impact, which works surprisingly well. While there are moments that seem intended to link his life experiences with themes found in Middle-earth, these connections aren't really explored, leaving the story feeling somewhat incomplete; nevertheless, it’s a visually appealing film.

Source on TMDB