W2TCH

Three Violent People (1956)

1956 • 1h 40m • Western • NR
On September 27, 2026
#24099▼ 2169
24099th by Pulse movie online
20.9PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

All reviews

John Chard on Three Violent People

7/10 · May 28, 2019

It's remarkable that you’re the first to recognize what happened to me on that day. Three Violent People was directed by Rudolph Maté and features a screenplay by James Edward Grant, adapted from a story co-written by Leonard Praskins and Barney Slater. The film stars Charlton Heston, Anne Baxter, Gilbert Roland, and Forrest Tucker. A Paramount Pictures production filmed in VistaVision with Technicolor photography by Loyal Griggs and music composed by Walter Scharf. The setting is post–Civil War Texas, where Confederate Captain Colt Saunders (Heston) marries a woman (Baxter) who carries secrets and whose family assets are coveted by opportunistic Carpetbaggers. Adding to the complications is Colt’s brother Cinch (Tryon), who lost an arm in childhood—an event for which Colt was responsible. The tensions between them, along with buried pasts and postwar greed, threaten the stability of the Bar “S” ranch. It's important to remember that people aren’t flawless; they simply aren’t. They make errors, and those mistakes bring consequences. Internally, they suffer for their actions. The film had a minimal impact when it was released in 1956, overshadowed by Heston’s other release that year, The Ten Commandments, which simultaneously launched him to greater fame. It didn't help that Three Violent People is intensely focused on its characters and leans heavily into melodrama. This isn’t an action-packed adventure; instead, it presents intriguing individuals engaged in lengthy conversations, with a well-developed screenplay bringing the main players to life, creating a compelling story that rewards viewers willing to engage with its deliberate pacing. The title, unfortunately, is misleading and doesn't do justice to the film. You were among those who avoided combat by hiding on General Butler’s staff while others faced danger in battle. The movie shares thematic similarities with another thoughtful Heston film from 1954, The Naked Jungle. A strong man marries a woman and is disturbed when he learns about her past. This sets the stage for an hour of relationship exploration before the story intensifies and unfolds with a suspenseful third act. Action is limited until that point, though there’s plenty of drama to maintain interest. It's also visually stunning, not just because of the beautiful landscapes surrounding the Bar "S" (Arizona), but also due to Loyal Griggs’ (of Shane fame) vibrant photography—a reason enough to seek out this undervalued Western. I have prepared the one with red hair for the buzzards. The performances from the main cast are uneven; Baxter and Heston have a decent chemistry, though they seem to be competing to dominate each scene. Baxter, who looks gorgeous throughout, overacts early on, while Heston abandons his usual subtlety later in the film. Gilbert Roland (from Cheyenne Autumn) delivers the strongest performance as Innocencio Ortega, the Bar “S” gran vaquero, exuding an undeniable coolness and providing a sense of humanity to the proceedings. Tryon, whose one-armed brother adds significant intrigue to the story, also gives a notably effective portrayal. The film’s shortcomings are apparent—some performances feel overly theatrical from actors who should have known better, and the villains lack depth. Nevertheless, it's a Western that resonates more with contemporary audiences than it did in the 1950s. The character-driven nature of the story can now be appreciated without expecting a typical "yee-haw" style film. This is one to engage with using your ears, eyes, and mind rather than just relying on adrenaline. It earns a rating of 7/10.

Source on TMDB