The movie industry frequently relies on romantic storylines, which can be exceptionally rewarding when crafted with care. The execution is critical; skillful handling results in emotionally resonant films, while poor treatment can severely damage their prospects. Writer-director Craig Brewer’s newest film unfortunately falls into the latter category, proving to be an unbalanced, predictable, contrived and overly sentimental dramatization of the lives of musical collaborators Mike Sardina (Hugh Jackman) and Claire Stingl (Kate Hudson). Drawing from director Greg Kohs’s 2008 documentary with the same title, this adaptation recounts the journey of Lightning and Thunder, a duo who gained recognition in their hometown of Milwaukee and nearby areas as a tribute act focused on the music of Neil Diamond, along with some songs by Patsy Cline. It's a story centered around opportunities for new beginnings, both having experienced difficulties in previous marriages, alongside individual struggles like Mike’s battle with alcoholism and heart disease and Claire’s experience with depression. They managed to overcome these obstacles, finding solace and healing through their music and love, which helped them regain stability and support each other when facing further adversity. Based on the description, one might expect a compelling romantic narrative. However, the film's inconsistent approach and occasionally saccharine portrayal ultimately prevent it from reaching its full potential. The initially cheerful, fairytale-like beginning clashes with the more serious tone of the later portion, requiring abrupt changes in storytelling to function effectively. Furthermore, while the kitsch appeal of the Neil Diamond songs is initially presented well—though sometimes a bit excessive, bordering on a concert film with brief scenes interspersed—it feels out of place when the movie shifts toward a darker mood, leaving audiences questioning how these disparate parts could be unified within a single story. The musical performances are genuinely respectful to the artists being celebrated, and the actors deliver strong portrayals, especially Kate Hudson’s performance, which earned her a Golden Globe Award nomination. Ultimately, though, there isn't enough substance to elevate this into one of those enduring Hollywood romances that audiences will remember fondly, representing a missed opportunity.

Source on TMDB