W2TCH

September 5 (2024)

2024 • 1h 34m • Drama, History • R
On September 24, 2026
#4863▲ 146
4863rd by Pulse movie online
46.4PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

All reviews

Brent Marchant on September 5

6/10 · Jan 12, 2025

It’s always a letdown when a film you anticipated doesn't meet your hopes. That’s unfortunately what happened with writer-director Tim Fehlbaum’s newest movie. This retelling of the day Black September terrorists took Israeli athletes hostage at the 1972 Munich Summer Games, regrettably, falls short in several areas. The story unfolds from the viewpoint of the ABC sportscasting team covering the events, and the film doesn't quite manage to communicate the feeling of urgency and immediacy that defined this human tragedy—a broadcast seen worldwide, reportedly drawing a larger audience than Neil Armstrong’s 1969 moon landing. While it deserves credit for seeming genuine and offering glimpses into the atmosphere within the broadcast headquarters, much of the story becomes bogged down in dialogue and technical details about what was happening around the TV crew, which isn't an especially effective way to portray an event that shook the world and fundamentally altered how crisis situations are reported. I wasn’t hoping for a sensationalized version, but I also didn’t want to feel bored by its awkward and uninspired account of events that had the entire planet captivated. The presentation of this situation—including details about that day and an exploration of the various moral questions surrounding its televised coverage—doesn't engage viewers in the same way as the actual events did. I distinctly recall that fateful day; it’s permanently imprinted in my memory as a 15-year-old, and it significantly influenced my later decision to study for and enter a career in journalism. Because of this personal connection, maybe I had too high expectations for what an entertainment film could achieve when dealing with such a significant event. Perhaps I was unrealistic in hoping that a movie could match the powerful journalistic accounts of something like this. Regardless, it doesn't excuse the disappointment of how this story has been told. Considering the number of disasters we face these days, one might argue that we don’t need to be reminded of those from the past. But if we choose to honor the idea of “never forget” when it comes to traumatic events, then those responsible for memorializing them should ensure their impact is undeniable—something this film fails to do.

Source on TMDB