It’s an acceptable film, but not something I’d feel compelled to revisit, and really only suitable for those who appreciate Steve Zahn's work. The movie contains elements that are undeniably silly, although in a way that proves entertaining. It seems logical that these performers would collaborate on a comedy, yet the choice to employ an "idiot boys club" concept combined with a comedic exploration of homosexuality feels perplexing. I don’t particularly care for Amanda Peet's performances (though I do enjoy “A Lot Like Love” and “Brockmire,” surprisingly both related to baseball), but she stands out as the strongest actor, by quite a significant margin. Her character is portrayed as highly intelligent and doesn't seem to belong in the same reality as the other characters—a design choice, most likely—and even participates in action scenes without those around her needing to join in. While I find Jason Biggs, Amanda Detmer, and R. Lee Ermey enjoyable, Steve Zahn isn’t someone whose work I typically seek out, and this isn't Jack Black at his finest. Considering that a large portion of the movie revolves around these two performers, there are many moments that feel irritating rather than amusing. The underlying structure is well-crafted, but the core idea and comedic writing are absurd, resulting in an inconsistent experience. I can’t wholeheartedly suggest it simply because there are so many alternatives available; the sheer number of comedies featuring Jason Biggs that rely on humor derived from mistreatment alone provides ample options for other films to watch instead.

Source on TMDB