It’s hard to classify *Santa Girl*; the film possesses qualities that suggest a truly awful movie, and yet, I ended up enjoying myself. There were moments where I chuckled, though it remains unclear whether my laughter was directed at the film or in appreciation of it. The visual effects are notably poor—I'm talking about some of the worst I’ve encountered—specifically scenes involving the Tooth Fairy and a sports car. The performances vary considerably. Barry Bostwick is appealing as Santa Claus, who has surprisingly limited screen time, while I thought McKayla Witt was quite good in her role as Pep. Jennifer Stone doesn’t particularly stand out as the lead; she has a few decent moments but largely fails to impress. The same can be said for Devon Werkheiser (Sam) and Joshua Cody (JR). Hank Stone delivers a reasonably steady performance as Jack Frost. I'm unsure why, but this film didn’t leave me with any negative feelings. However, it’s certainly not a good movie either, so I’m giving it 2½ stars—which, considering the overall quality, is actually quite generous.

Source on TMDB