W2TCH

The Revisionaries (2012)

2012 • 1h 32m • Documentary • Not Rated
On October 3, 2026
#98925
98925th by Pulse movie online
1.1PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

All reviews

Peter McGinn on The Revisionaries

9/10 · Apr 5, 2020

It's hard to see how anyone involved with the creationism debate could have been satisfied by this film. From a scientific perspective, it seems like Mr. McElroy was handled gently; his beliefs about the Earth being only 6,000 years old and rejecting evolution are simply presented, left to be evaluated on their own. No one challenges him, for example, with questions about how penguins could have traveled vast distances to join the ark alongside dinosaurs and a small group of humans. Perhaps the Earth wasn’t just younger than scientists believe, but also smaller. On the other hand, those who advocate for creationism might feel let down because the film highlights their practices, which could potentially complicate future revisions of history and science in textbooks. I also noticed that the creationists were able to bring in polished experts from elsewhere, while the people representing science were limited to individuals from Texas. That scientist was articulate and intelligent, but considering the broader context raised by the Social Studies issues, it seemed like someone with more knowledge of history and philosophy might have been helpful. It doesn’t really matter, though, since partisan politics often dictates outcomes regardless. There was a certain irony in Mr. McElroy claiming to be standing against experts because somebody needed to (without explaining why), only to then position himself as an expert when instructing young students about the ark's size and the placement of dinosaurs and their waste. A memorable moment occurred when he asked, "Were there dinosaurs on the ark?" and the children responded, "No!" Clearly, he had a lot of work ahead of him in shifting their perspectives to align with his particular worldview. A key takeaway is something political organizers from all sides would likely agree on: if you feel your vote or input doesn’t matter much in national or statewide elections, you're not entirely wrong. Of course, every vote does count. But as elections focus on county or city issues, you can actually make a difference, and allowing others to handle things completely can be risky—even with good intentions, it can lead to decisions supported by only a small fraction of the public. So, it’s worth attending or at least following your local council meetings. We all get things wrong sometimes, but there aren't many rewards for being uninformed or indifferent. This film could have been made in countless different ways and from numerous viewpoints, but it is valuable that at least one version exists showing how history and science in school textbooks can be altered or removed to support a political agenda—any political agenda.

Source on TMDB