“MacKenna’s Gold,” a 1969 Western, explores the madness of gold fever and generates considerable suspense surrounding the possibility of a hidden canyon filled with gold. Whether this location actually exists is left open to question. Film historian Brian Garfield, author of "Death Wish" and “Western Films," dismissed "MacKenna's Gold," calling it "the most expensive star-studded two-hour ‘B’ movie ever made; a gargantuan dud of absolutely stunning dreadfulness.” It’s hard to believe that this film has no positive attributes. Let me mention a few: The cast is exceptional, featuring Gregory Peck, Omar Sharif, Ted Cassidy, Julie Newmar, Telly Savalas, Carmilla Sparv and others, though many have smaller roles; the Western score by Quincy Jones is among the best ever composed, comparable to those of "How the West Was Won," "Rio Lobo,” “Duel at Diablo,” "Bandolero!" "Bonanza," "The Magnificent Seven" and "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly." Also noteworthy is the theme song, "Old Turkey Buzzard," performed by Jose Feliciano and written by Jones; the film showcases impressive locations (Utah, Arizona, Rogue River Oregon) and beautiful cinematography. Despite a noticeable comic book feel—which likely explains Garfield's assessment of it as a “B” movie—the story is presented with complete seriousness and manages to hold your attention while building anticipation about the fabled canyon. Gregory Peck, portraying Marshal MacKenna, and Carmilla Sparv are clearly meant to be the "good guys." The film was produced during a period in the late 1960s when Western characters often lacked appeal or were morally ambiguous (as seen in films like "The Wild Bunch," "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly" and "Macho Callahan"), but this movie does offer some likable protagonists. Omar Sharif delivers an excellent performance as the Mexican bandit “Colorado,” a somewhat unusual role for him, though he throws himself into it with such energy that he seems perfectly suited to the part. Ted Cassidy, known for his role as "Lurch" on The Addams Family television series, plays the imposing and silent Indian warrior Hachita, embodying the character convincingly. Julie Newmar is also memorable as a wild Native American woman; male viewers may be interested in knowing that she appears nude in a swimming scene. Quincy Jones’ opening score and the theme song “Old Turkey Buzzard” are so captivating (especially when paired with the stunning Southwestern scenery) that I sometimes just play the beginning of the film, which lasts a full 6-8 minutes. Some have criticized "Old Turkey Buzzard" as being cheesy, but even someone who doesn’t typically enjoy country/western music can appreciate its power; it effectively comments on humanity's fleeting existence and the obsessive nature of gold fever. While “MacKenna’s Gold” certainly lacks the stark realism found in a film like "The Wild Bunch," it remains a serious movie despite certain cartoonish elements. One could also find fault with the somewhat unsuccessful special effects miniature work, but that is not essential; what matters most is the film's ability to entertain. Ultimately, “MacKenna’s Gold” provides entertainment. The film has a running time of 2 hours and 8 minutes. GRADE: B

Source on TMDB