It speaks volumes about Michael Caine’s appeal that I refrained from assigning it a one-star rating. As someone of Scottish heritage, I should have found it objectionable. Surprisingly, however, it isn’t entirely bad. The accent is inconsistent, to be sure, but the central narrative manages to hold together adequately. The story begins with "David Balfour" (Lawrence Douglas) traveling to his uncle "Ebenezer" (Donald Pleasance) to inform him of his father's death. The grasping old man has no plans to distribute his limited wealth and soon "Davie" finds himself sailing across the sea, guided by "Capt. Hoseason" (Jack Hawkins). Their ship collides with a smaller vessel, which introduces us to the Jacobite, tartan-wearing Caine ("Alan Breck Stewart"), who is evading King George’s soldiers. Following an actual struggle to escape the brig, they experience various escapades, become entangled in a significant assassination plot, and ultimately both attempt to accomplish their goals against considerable obstacles. The film is visually agreeable, and the musical score complements the beautiful Scottish scenery. The acting? Well, Hawkins seems to have indulged excessively in port; Trevor Howard performs well as the deceptive Lord Advocate, and young Douglas does a commendable job portraying the innocent but honorable "Balfour." Ultimately, it hinges on Michael Caine’s performance - and despite its numerous shortcomings, there's no denying that the robust adventure story provides sufficient support to prevent it from becoming the ridiculous failure it easily could have been. It doesn’t measure up to the 1959 Disney adaptation, but I didn't dislike it.

Source on TMDB