Despite what some might claim, a fresh coat of paint can't transform a pig. This film unfortunately illustrates that point exactly; it's a disappointing effort at intelligent horror from the writer-director team of Scott Beck and Bryan Woods. The story follows two inexperienced Mormon missionaries, portrayed by Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East, who visit the isolated home of an odd, talkative middle-aged man (Hugh Grant) hoping to convert him. This leads to a lengthy discussion about religious beliefs – which is somewhat interesting initially – but it soon devolves into rambling sequences featuring disconnected, incomplete pieces that test the viewer’s tolerance. The dialogue becomes increasingly artificial and forced, weakened by unbelievable character arcs, especially concerning the two young women who start delivering lines that seem out of place given their supposed naiveté and limited perspective. Then, seemingly in a last-ditch effort to hold onto viewers, the movie shifts into a drawn-out slasher film, though it does boast better production values than most movies of its kind. The script appears to draw heavily from numerous religious, philosophical, and cinematic sources; some have even suggested comparisons to “The Butterfly Effect” and “Matrix.” While Grant and his fellow actors provide commendable performances as the three central characters, their efforts aren’t sufficient to overcome the fundamental flaws in the story, regardless of any attempts to improve it. I'm genuinely puzzled by the positive reception this film has received considering its tedious plot and pretentious, mostly unnecessary approach – an experiment that simply doesn’t succeed. As someone who appreciates smart horror movies and their goal of improving upon classic films within the genre, I’m seriously let down that the talented creators behind “A Quiet Place” haven't produced something stronger; a result that feels almost sacrilegious in itself.

Source on TMDB