W2TCH

Decision at Sundown (1957)

1957 • 1h 18m • Western • Approved
On September 25, 2026
#20950▼ 3991
20950th by Pulse movie online
22.6PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

All reviews

talisencrw on Decision at Sundown

8/10 · May 1, 2016

While not quite reaching the heights of other Westerns directed by Scott and Boetticher like 'Buchanan Rides Alone' or 'The Tall T', this film is still exceptionally good and would pair well with 'High Noon'. Both are excellent examples of stories about individuals finding the courage to confront local inaction and resolve issues plaguing a town. What sets this apart is Bart Allison, Scott’s character, who is driven by a desire for retribution—a quest that has taken three years—after his wife was led astray (and subsequently took her own life in shame). He initially believed his wife possessed a stronger moral compass and wouldn't have acted so willingly. However, it becomes clear that the entire town, even his closest friend, held a different perspective. It’s a compelling exploration of how far people will go to correct injustices they encounter. Allison's disappointment with the community for permitting another wrong to occur roughly halfway through the film is particularly memorable and lingers afterward. I was inclined to award it a higher score if not for an easily noticeable, unprofessional error that occurs approximately ten minutes in: during one woman’s dialogue, an actor’s arm completely blocks her mouth throughout her entire speech. It's a small detail, perhaps, but it’s surprising that no one noticed it before the film's release, particularly given Boetticher's experience as director.

Source on TMDB