W2TCH

Dark City (1998)

1998 • 1h 41m • Science Fiction, Mystery • R
On September 27, 2026
#1037▼ 455
1037th by Pulse movie online
52.5PULSEPulse MeterOur daily Pulse Meter measures public activity and popularity signals across the web.How it works →

All reviews

John Chard on Dark City

9/10 · Sep 25, 2014

Welcome To Shell Beach. Alex Proyas directed Dark City, also co-writing the screenplay with Leon Dobbs and David S. Goyer. The cast includes Rufus Sewell, William Hurt, Jennifer Connelly, Kiefer Sutherland, Richard O'Brien, and Ian Richardson. Trevor Jones composed the music, and Dariusz Wolski was the cinematographer. The film begins with a man waking up in a dingy hotel bathroom; he discovers a dead girl in another room and realizes he can’t remember who he is or how he got there. Many fans of Blade Runner have been hoping for something similar to emerge, but Alex Proyas has already created that movie. Dark City, despite its initial struggles with box office receipts and studio interference, remains an undervalued cult film. Its reputation was further damaged when The Matrix appeared the following year; many assumed Proyas’s film was a copy of The Matrix, pushing it even further out of the sci-fi noir conversation. While Dark City pays homage to earlier films, it has also influenced later works—reportedly, Nolan took notes from it while making Inception. Dark City is a visually striking film noir. Some have criticized it as style over substance, something Proyas strongly disputes, especially with the availability of his director's cut. The story revolves around complex characters living in a world without daylight, whose memories are unreliable; it soon becomes clear that strange alien beings are orchestrating events. These aliens, dressed in black trench coats and hats, possess special abilities, and their motives are revealed gradually. John Murdoch (Sewell) is the only one standing in their way, but he’s an amnesiac caught up in a noir mystery, and his quest to uncover the truth becomes our own as well. The search for identity and the truth drives the narrative forward. Murdoch's confusion places him at the center of both an existential crisis and a serial killer investigation. As he grapples with these issues, it also appears that he has a beautiful wife (Connelly), and she may have been unfaithful. And why is he drawn to Shell Beach? The visuals are undeniably captivating. With classic film noir characters—Hurt’s weary detective, Sewell's amnesiac, and Connelly's alluring singer—Proyas incorporates German expressionism while creating a striking neo-noir color palette. Greens and reds pop from the screen, contrasting with murky browns and golds that line the angular city streets, setting the stage for changing perceptions and revelations. Recurring motifs of swirls and circles contribute to the atmosphere, and at the film’s midpoint, Proyas showcases his techniques as the city itself shifts and moves, blending Metropolis and Gotham while the humans sleep. The acting isn't exceptional (Sutherland is more irritating than impressive), but it doesn’t really need to be; everyone looks great in their roles. The story is admittedly bizarre—I found it much easier to appreciate after a few drinks! (I watched it three times within 48 hours!) Proyas admits the film isn't perfect, but he believes it deserves more recognition and that people should seek out his director’s cut. Like Roger Ebert, who championed Dark City, I consider this a unique and wonderful sci-fi noir experience—a film worthy of being viewed alongside Blade Runner, and I don't say that lightly. 9/10

Source on TMDB