This Southern Gothic fantasy, “Beautiful Creatures” (2013), feels excessively theatrical and displays an apparent aversion to Christianity. The story unfolds in a small South Carolina town where a high school student with college aspirations finds himself drawn to a mysterious new girl who has recently moved in with her unusual uncle at his unsettling Antebellum home. He discovers that they are "casters"—immortals possessing magical abilities—and that a malevolent family member (Emma Thompson) desires Lena for nefarious purposes. The film is an adaptation of the first installment in “The Caster Chronicles” by Kami Garcia and Margaret Stohl, though devotees of the book series claim it's a notably inaccurate translation to the screen. As I haven’t encountered any of the source material myself, this aspect didn’t impact my viewing experience. While the production values are evident—the sets, costumes, cast, and music all appear well-funded given the $60 million budget—and the Southern Gothic atmosphere is quite striking, particularly in the initial act, the tone veers into campiness. The characters often feel exaggerated and cartoonish, reminiscent of Stephen King’s earlier adaptations like "Silver Bullet" and "Needful Things," but amplified further. A significant issue lies with the film's pronounced anti-Christian bias. While I appreciate movies that critique harmful religious legalism—like “The Mist” (2007)—the stereotypes presented here are so heavy-handed they lack authenticity. There’s no counterbalancing portrayal of positive believers, unlike in "The Mist." The movie seems to suggest that all Christians are hateful, judgmental, and quick to condemn. It's a shortcut for writers who avoid developing nuanced characters. For example, on Lena’s first day of school, two girls immediately label her as “satanic” simply because she resides at the eerie plantation, then proceed to pray aloud for her. This feels contrived and pulls you out of the story; it doesn't reflect reality even in rural areas where one is more likely to encounter mockery from non-believers than persecution from devout Christians. The plot also strains credibility by portraying all prominent community leaders as uniformly “evil” fundamentalists attending the same church. The latter portion attempts a clumsy correction, briefly introducing a sympathetic Christian character and featuring a brief sermon on sacrifice from the pastor, but it’s an insufficient remedy for alienating much of the audience with its earlier misrepresentations. Another drawback is the excessive amount of make-out scenes between the two main characters; the girl is only fifteen years old. While teenagers do kiss, the frequency feels exaggerated and distracting. If you're seeking a more successful fantasy/horror film based on a young adult book series, I’d recommend "Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant" (2009) instead. The movie has a running time of 2 hours and 4 minutes and was filmed entirely in Louisiana, specifically in Covington, Madisonville, Batchelor, St. Francisville, and New Orleans. GRADE: C/C- (4.5/10)

Source on TMDB