It’s striking how often people say “I should have known” after watching "This Is It," and I suspect the same will be true of this film. Many viewers outside of English-speaking countries may not even know who Michael Jackson was, and my own experience mirrors that—before seeing this documentary, I wasn't familiar with Amy Winehouse or her music. So, I want to thank the director for creating a film that introduced me to her story, and congratulate him on his Oscar nomination. The movie felt incomplete. Like most documentaries, it’s assembled from recorded audio and video clips, along with interviews from people she worked with and those close to her. It's like putting together a puzzle, but the pieces were arranged in chronological order. Of course, you won’t get the whole truth from these sources; many aspects remain mysterious. This film offers perspectives on Amy’s character from various viewpoints, but ultimate honesty and accuracy are something only she could have provided—something we'll never know because she can't share what she experienced in her life, just as each of us holds private truths about our own journeys. I agree that films, especially documentaries, simply cannot encompass an entire person’s life within a two-hour timeframe, and it isn't fair for viewers to judge someone based on such a limited portrayal. The ending felt abrupt, as if they had run out of footage documenting the events leading up to her death. Apparently, Amy’s father wasn’t pleased with how the film depicted his daughter, particularly the final years of her life. Few people truly know how accurate this movie is, but it's clear that he didn’t provide the kind of support she needed as a child. Every child deserves good parenting, and I believe Amy’s struggles began in her childhood. However, after becoming more independent during adolescence, she lost her way, especially as fame came pouring in. She undoubtedly possessed an extraordinary voice, but lacked guidance on how to manage it. Her marriage, according to this film, seems to have marked the beginning of a downward spiral. > "When you looked at her lyrical and melodic capability, > she was a very old soul in a very young body." I've only seen this documentary and "Cartel Land" among the Academy Award nominees, but I believe this film has a strong chance of winning Best Documentary Feature. Amy’s story certainly warrants being told as a full-length movie, and I would be interested in seeing that happen. It reminded me of a question about why Bill Gates isn't celebrated like Steve Jobs—despite both men achieving significant contributions to computer technology. The explanation was that Bill Gates came from a financially stable family who excelled academically and enjoyed an easy life with support from all sides, while Steve Jobs was the child of immigrant parents who faced considerable challenges in his pursuit of success. His struggles resonated with people. This film has qualities that are both inspiring—highlighting Amy’s achievements—and cautionary—illustrating lessons learned from her personal life. Everyone deals with their own problems, and Amy was no exception. Drug and alcohol addiction is a common problem among celebrities; Heath Ledger, Philip Seymour Hoffman, and many others have been victims of this struggle. That doesn't negate their accomplishments; it simply reveals another facet of their lives. Ultimately, humans pursue what they desire, but there are limits to everything—and exceeding those limits often leads to self-destruction. It’s a very good movie. If you were already familiar with Amy and want to understand her better, or if you're new to her story and curious about it, this is worth watching. 8/10

Source on TMDB