The film boasts impressive visuals and technical achievements, but it would greatly benefit from a more polished script and better character development. I’m not sure if others feel this way, but I believe horror movies are most effective when they demonstrate some intelligence in both the writing and how the characters behave, and when the central villain remains enigmatic and capable of surprising viewers. I enjoyed “Prometheus,” which was surprisingly good despite its confusing story. This film strengthens the connection between that movie and the "Alien" franchise. The narrative follows the "Covenant," a spacecraft carrying colonists in suspended animation, as it receives an unusual signal from a planet seemingly ideal for life—but quickly discovers they’ve landed somewhere they shouldn't be. After watching, I felt like I had seen something potentially strong that ultimately fell short when compared to the earlier films. Perhaps it’s best not to compare it at all, even though the temptation is understandable and difficult to resist. Let’s begin with what works well. The film is visually stunning, a real treat for science fiction enthusiasts and those who appreciate movies rich in special effects, CGI, or incredibly detailed sets. It's clear that a significant portion of the budget was allocated to computer graphics artists, set designers, costume creators, and cinematographers—and that investment has paid off handsomely. The excellent soundtrack and sound design further enhance the experience. There are plenty of suspenseful moments; it’s one of those movies where tension is constant, but it doesn't truly elicit fear. Unfortunately, this seems to be essentially all the movie has to offer. While fans of the "Alien" franchise will appreciate how the film clarifies some unresolved plot points from other installments, like “Prometheus,” I agree with that assessment—though it’s not something we should exaggerate its importance because it was really the minimum expected from this production. The script is frankly disappointing; it feels lazy, relying heavily on elements established in previous films and adding very little new. It introduces some new creatures, related to the original xenomorphs, but that's the extent of it. The human characters lack depth and feel like they’re simply waiting for their demise. The film begins promisingly, but becomes slow and repetitive as its plot grows predictable. I respect Ridley Scott's work; he is undoubtedly a skilled director with an impressive track record. However, it's hard to ignore the fact that he missed the mark here. The director seemed overly focused on the possibilities of CGI, neglecting the narrative, editing, and direction of the actors. Michael Fassbender delivers a standout performance, arguably one of his best to date. Katherine Waterston also does commendable work. The rest of the cast doesn’t have enough opportunity or material to make a significant impact.

Source on TMDB