Critics have been too harsh on this film; it's remarkable from beginning to end, giving audiences exactly what they want in a motion picture. Mandy Moore gives an impressive performance filled with emotion that holds your attention completely. Her acting is both fascinating and touching, demonstrating the range of her abilities. I would place this movie among my all-time favorites—it’s within my top 25 films. Certain problems or gaps in the plot might not appeal to everyone, but the music is superb and the story itself is interesting. The entire ensemble cast, from the main actors to those in smaller roles, provides outstanding work that advances the story. Regardless of any imperfections, I feel this movie has been wrongly disregarded and should be more widely praised for its merits.

Source on TMDB